Controversial
changes to Cambrian Caving Council Constitution
- from your Committee
Dear Club member,
Please find
linked documents relating to the AGM of the Cambrian
Caving Council (CCC) which is to be held on the 15th of March
2015 in Bettws Y Coed. As members of a CCC member club, all SWCC
members are entitled to attend this meeting and to speak if they
wish to, but not to vote. Bernie Woodley will be attending the meeting
as the SWCC voting representative. CCC Agenda
- Constitution
- Proposed
Amendments
The Committee
encourages all members to read the linked documents as the proposed
constitutional amendments represent a potentially significant change
in the ethos of the Council and its relationships with the Clubs
it represents.
Firstly, the
CCC is proposing to amend clause 4.2 in the Guiding Principles section.
The current wording is That the landowners and tenants of
property containing caves have the right to grant or withhold access.
The proposed amendment is That any rights held by the landowners
and tenants of property containing caves to grant or withhold access
be respected
This seemingly
innocuous change actually has significant ramifications. We have
recently seen a large
debate and a referendum on the rights to access. This change
in wording could, in effect give those who believe that CROW already
applies to caving (an opinion as yet untested in any legal binding
way) a perceived justification to cave without gaining landowner
permission since they do not believe that the landowner has any
rights to refuse or grant access. There is great potential for this
interpretation to severely damage existing relationships with landowners
and any longer term negotiations.
Secondly, there
is a proposed change to the makeup of the Council itself.
According to
clause 7.3, currently Each officer and representative shall
be a member of a full Member-Club of at least one years standing.
The proposed
change is that Each Officer and representative shall be a
member of a Full Member-Club, or an Associate Member of the Council,
of at least one year's standing.
This is also
a subtle yet very significant change. It could allow an individual
who has chosen not to belong to any of the 50 or so member clubs
active in Wales to become an elected officer with a position of
influence on the very council that represents the interests of those
clubs and therefore goes against the Councils own statement on the
front page of their website The Cambrian Caving Council
is the National Association for caving in the Principality, it is
comprised of caving clubs or similar organisations therein or organisations
with major speleological interests or establishments therein. It
represents their interests in Wales, The Marches and the Forest
of Dean on a regional basis within the UK context, whilst maintaining
its position as an independent autonomous body within the Principality
For these reasons,
Bernie will be attending the meeting with a mandate from the committee
to vote against the proposed constitutional ammendments.
Significant
changes were allowed to happen at the last CCC AGM because only
11 of the eligible clubs attended. We would urge anybody who is
available to attend this meeting and support Bernie. If you would
like to discuss the Clubs relationship with CCC in more detail,
please contact any Committee
member.
|